AARP.org

Your Financial Future: It’s No Free Lunch

If you’re bombarded with invitations from financial advisers, here’s how to check up on your host

By: Martha M. Hamilton | Source: AARP Bulletin Today | July 23, 2009

SEE ALSO

Solicitations Are Tricky Business
Beware of automated phone calls that try to sell you extended warranties or get you to sign up for credit cards. More>>

The High Cost of Free Lunch Seminars
The promise of a free meal is just to get you in the door. More>>

Stop Dishonest Telemarketers
While dishonest telemarketers call people of all ages, backgrounds and incomes, they often make up to 80 percent of their calls to older consumers. More>>

ARCHIVE

Read more Your Financial Future columns.

It’s actually sort of amazing. Here you are in your late 50s or early 60s, when you might think your powers of attraction are waning, and suddenly, you’re popular!

Offers of free lunches and free dinners begin pouring in. What a deal! But then you think, maybe it’s not me that’s the big attraction. Maybe it’s my money.

And it is. The would-be investment advisers offering the free meals know where the money is, and a lot of it is in the hands of retirees and those approaching retirement. About $12.4 trillion was stashed away in 401(k)s, IRAs and other retirement savings accounts in 2008, according to global consulting firm Wyatt Watson Worldwide. And there are those—scrupulous and unscrupulous—who want to tell you how to invest it.

If you’ve wanted to attend one of these lunches or dinners, hoping that you might get legitimate advice but concerned that you might be pressured to buy something that’s not in your interest, there is a new tool to empower you. It’s AARP’s Free Lunch Seminar Monitor program.

The free lunch checklist

Launched last October, the program provides volunteers with a questionnaire to take to the free meals. Their answers provide useful information to members of the North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA), a member organization representing all U.S. state securities regulators that cosponsors the program along with the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, an independent securities regulator.

The “What to Listen for Checklist” is designed to test the legitimacy of the program and the presenters. For example:

• Did the speaker say or suggest in any way that AARP, the federal Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), NASAA or a state regulator was involved, had endorsed the session or the product, had sponsored the event, or had provided your name for the invitation list?

• Were high-pressure phrases, such as “You have to decide today” or “Only a few opportunities are left,” used in the seminar?

AARP’s project manager for financial security, Andrés Castillo, said that thousands of invitations have been sent and hundreds of completed checklists have been collected from volunteers. Some of these may lead to state enforcement actions, he said, but because the project is so new, it’s hard to tell how many.

Why the project was started

“Free lunch seminars aren’t necessarily bad,” said Castillo, but the checklist program was started because “we’d heard too many stories from our members and others that attend these meetings and are talked into investing in products that are not suitable or that are completely nonexistent, bogus products.”

Judging from the comments the AARP Free Lunch Seminar Monitor program has collected, many operators are trying to sell equity-indexed annuities, an insurance product that state regulators say is often unsuitable for older investors because they can incur steep surrender charges if they need their money early.

Another popular product is living trusts, for which investors are charged a relatively high fee for language that is often boilerplate, and then incur additional legal fees when they want to make changes.

Len Bach calls these trusts “extravagant wills.” Bach, a retired contract and purchasing manager who lives in Murrysville, Pa., and his wife are both consumer activists who have taken up monitoring free lunches. “The dinners themselves are usually quite good,” he said, “because they can’t lure you in with a bad meal.”

The follow-up

The dinners are just the entry point, he said. What the presenters are really after is a follow-up meeting, either at their offices or your home. “They do the soft presentation along with ingratiating themselves with their charm and personalities,” but at the same time they also try to create fear among attendees. Bach said he and his wife generally take the second step of the home visit to try to assess what’s really being sold.

They’ve encountered a range of pitchmen, including legitimate investment advisers, brokers pushing products that generate high commissions but that are not necessarily the best investment for the buyers, and “people who peddled products to us that were not licensed or registered.”

On one occasion, they were asked by an adviser to turn over $100,000 without any paperwork to document the transfer. “In checking his credentials, we found he was not licensed and the investment product wasn’t registered,” Bach said.

The target group is you

Fred Joseph, the securities commissioner for the state of Colorado and also the president of NASAA, said the monitoring program was badly needed. In his office’s investigations, most victims of investment wrongdoing have been older investors. Now the would-be victims are helping to find the victimizers. “It’s one way we can put more people out in the field. We obviously can’t be everywhere,” Joseph said.

So the next time you get an invitation to a free lunch or dinner, click on the No Free Lunch websiteand print out a checklist. You can enjoy that free lunch or dinner, but do it with a checklist and a grain of salt.


Martha M. Hamilton, formerly with the Washington Post, writes a regular column, Your Financial Future, for AARP Bulletin Today.

preview


More In Personal Finance